ISSN: 0970-938X (Print) | 0976-1683 (Electronic)

Biomedical Research

An International Journal of Medical Sciences

Research Article - Biomedical Research (2018) Volume 29, Issue 1

Evaluation of cardiovascular complexities and quality of life related to health in Chinese patients with thyrotoxic heart disease secondary to toxic diffuse goiter

Dacheng Yang*#, Fengjun Liu#, Teng Ma

Department of Cardiovasology, Tengzhou Central People’s Hospital, Shandong, PR China

#These authors contributed equally to this work

*Corresponding Author:
Dacheng Yang
Department of Cardiovasology
Tengzhou Central People’s Hospital
No.181, Xingtan Road, Tengzhou 277500, Shandong, PR China

Accepted date: May 12, 2016

Visit for more related articles at Biomedical Research


The common reason behind the development of thyrotoxic heart disease is toxic diffuse goiter via hyperthyroidism. The effect of cardiovascular complexities and quality of life related to health in Chinese patients with thyrotoxic heart disease secondary to toxic diffuse goiter has been evaluated. During July 2013-June 2015 patients were diagnosed with thyrotoxic heart disease secondary to toxic diffuse goiter. Clinical assessment was performed at baseline and after restoration of euthyroid state follow-up. A questionnaire was created and used to study the quality of life related to health in them. Cohort study data for 73 patients was obtained. However, around half (35) of these patients with thyrotoxic heart disease secondary to toxic diffuse goiter were agreed to participate further in investigation of their quality of life related to health. The frequency of cardiovascular complexities before and after anti-thyroid therapy was recorded. A significant reduction in respective values was observed as: thyrotoxic cardiomyopathy (78% vs. 24%), ventricular extrasystole (72% vs. 7%), systolic blood pressure (158 vs. 126; in mm), diastolic blood pressure (85 vs. 68; in mm), congestive cardiac failure (68 vs. 18; in %), resting heart rate (124 vs. 76; in bpm) and atrial fibrillation (71 vs. 19; in %). In all the domains, improvement in quality of life related to health was observed. There is a strong association of reduction in cardiovascular complexities and of increment in quality of life related to health with respect to restoration of euthyroidism in Chinese patients.


Cardiovascular complexities, Quality of life related to health, Thyrotoxic heart disease, Toxic diffuse goiter.


Thyrotoxic heart disease has been classified as the development of various cardiovascular complexities which results because the excess of thyroid hormones affect peripheral vasculature and cardiac myocytes, directly. It could manifest as thyrotoxic cardiomyopathy, ventricular extrasystole, congestive cardiac failure, elevated resting heart rate, atrial fibrillation, arterial high blood pressure (bp), and cardiac hypertrophy [1-4]. The common cause behind thyrotoxic heart disease is toxic diffuse goiter (TDG) [5], which is associated with hyperthyroidism constituting up to 5% of all endocrine disorders in several countries [6,7]. Besides, the reason behind the development of psychiatric disorders is the deregulation of thyroid hormones and its influence on neurotransmitters through hyperthyroidism [8,9].

Quality of life related to health (QLrH) includes anxiety and depression as prime dimensions along with other dimensions as pain, mobility, discomfort, self-care etc. A number of clinical studies have suggested that hyperthyroidism may lead to anxiety and depression [10-13]. Concurrently, anxiety and depression may lead to thyroid abnormalities [14,15] as well as it may lead to various cardiovascular-based risks or even to cardiovascular-based deaths [16] and thus it can be said that depression and cardiovascular-related results are interrelated and this has been established in recent past [17-21]. Even then, studies in which depression has been assessed by means of interview-validated questionnaires have not been explored much and thus the precise relationship between hyperthyroidism and depression remains unclear. QLrH diminish due to thyrotoxic heart disease along with TDG [22-24]. Anti-thyroid drugs and β-adrenergic receptor antagonists are the preferential action to deal with TDG in Europe and Southeast Asia [25,26] because they eliminated hyperthyroidism and normalized the cardiovascular dimensions along with as well as QLrH [27-29]. Several authors have reported the effect of QLrH in different patients with hyperthyroidism or cardiovascular complexities [22-24,30-32] but up to a limited extent and so far the features of TDG in Chinese patients are less known. Thus our study is the first study of its own kind to reveal the association of thyrotoxic heart disease secondary to TDG with specific focus on quality of life related to health in Chinese patients.

Materials and Methods

The ethical committee of Tengzhou Central People’s Hospital (China) has approved the study and consent procedure. The name of chairperson of ethics committee was Fengchun Wang, the identification of ethical committee was 20153545431, the protocol number and data of approval is June 4th of 2013. Written consent of all the participants who participated in the study was taken.

The patients were diagnosed between July 2013 to June 2015. Total 1252 patients were diagnosed with TDG among 2687 patients suffering from hyperthyroidism. Only 93 patients were appeared with thyrotoxic heart disease and hence participated in our study. Finally follow-up data and clinical information for 73 patients were obtained. Of these, only 35 patients with thyrotoxic heart disease secondary to TDG were further participated in QLrH investigation section of our study. A criterion for inclusion of patients was set in which TDG was diagnosed only with thyroid hormone disease and overt hyperthyroidism. Except this, the rest of the patients suffering from several diseases such as lung/liver failures, cancer or other infectious disease, any kind of history of coronary thrombosis or cardiac failures, secondary arterial high blood pressure, or any other congenital cardiac defects were excluded. An anti-thyroid therapy (AtT) was applied to all the patients using carbimazole with titration regimen method. However, in order to treat cardiological complexities, patients were administered with three types of medicines such as angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitor (captopril), β- adrenergic receptor antagonist (atenolol) or angiotensin II receptor blocker (fimasartan) (Table 1). During this study the patients were diagnosed before AtT (at baseline) means when TDG was diagnosed and after the follow up means establishment of stable euthyroidism. Follow up with respect to thyroid based and cardiovascular based examinations and investigation of QLrH section have included these two assessments.

Medicine Captopril Atenolol Fimasartan
Medicine’s action Angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor ß-Adrenergic receptor antagonist Angiotensin II receptor blocker
AtT (at baseline) Daily dosage* 10/5-42 72/30-100 45/10-55
n 54 (74%) 73 (100%) 4 (5%)
AtT (after follow up) Daily dosage* 5.2/ 2.8-6 39/14-52.2 0
n 16 (22%) 16 (22%) 0

Table 1: Medical treatment of cardiological complexities before the antithyroid therapy (AtT) and after the follow-up.

Investigation of QLrH section

A questionnaire based upon visual analogue score system (VASS) was set and used for the investigation of QLrH section. Briefly, the questionnaire was answered by patients with respect to six dimensions as anxiety, depression, pain, mobility, discomfort and self-care in five levels of problems as: Level 1 (for no problem), Level 2 (for slight problem), Level 3 (for moderate problem), Level 4 (for severe problem) and Level 5 (for extreme problem). The overall health status of patients was rated as zero for the worst health care and as hundred for the best health care, using the vertical VASS as per previous report [33].

Diagnosis of toxic diffuse gland

For this purpose, a minimum of two parameters from: diffuse goiter, thyroid eye disease, increased level of thyroidstimulating hormone (TSH) receptor antibodies (TRAb), thyroid peroxidase antibodies (TPOAb) accompanied with high concentrations of serum-free thyroid hormones such as triiodothyronine (free T3), its prohormone, thyroxine (free T4) and TSH (<0.1 mIU/L) was chosen in order to get biochemical evidence of overt hyperthyroidism in the patients which in turn established the diagnosis of TDG. The normal concentrations of TRAb and TPOAb were less than 1.61 IU/L and 32 kIU/L, respectively. Cobas E 411 analyzer (Roshe Diagnostics GmbH, Germany) was used for evaluation of thyroid by blood testing and physical examination. Besides, Sonoline Sienna (Siemens, Germany) was used for ultrasonography purpose with respect to evaluation of thyroid.

Cardiovascular complexities assessment

Heartbeat per minute (bpm) was manually evaluated at the radial artery and it was used to determine the resting heart rate. As per reported guidelines [34,35], thyrotoxic heart disease was confirmed in patients with manifestations of arterial high blood pressure, ventricular extrasystole, congestive cardiac failure, atrial fibrillation or thyrotoxic cardiomyopathy. However, manual digital BP monitor (Little Doctor, Singapore) was used to measure the office bp and mean of three was considered. The patients having systolic bp ≥ 140 mm Hg and/or diastolic bp ≥ 90 mm Hg were considered as patients of arterial high bp. Electrocardiography was performed by 12- leads-3-channel ECG machine ECG300G (CONTEC, China). EnVisor C Ultrasound System (Philips, USA) was used for echocardiography purpose as per previous report [36] in order to measure several parameters of the heart as shown in Table 2. Mosteller formula [37] was used to determine body surface area (BSA). With the assistance of body weight (in kg) per height (in m2), body mass index (BMI) was calculated.

  Features Patients (n=73)
Before AtT After AtT
Physiological features Assessment Heart rate, bpm
Mean, median, range
124, 122, 95-195 76, 73, 65-105
Systolic bp, mm Hg
Mean, median, range
158, 156, 135-195 126, 125, 75-160
Diastolic bp,mm Hg
Mean, median, range
85, 82, 60-120 68, 66, 55-80
Pulse bp, mm Hg
Mean, median, range
73, 70, 45-115 55, 54, 50-80
Heart sizes features Assessment Left ventricular mass, g
Mean, median, range
230, 228, 120-375 195, 192, 109-401
Left ventricular mass index, g/m2
Mean, median, range
131, 126, 68-227 108, 101, 58-221
Left atrium dimension, cm
Mean, median, range
4.1, 3.9, 3.3-5.8 3.8, 3.6, 3.2-4.8
Interventricular septum wall thickness, cm
Mean, median, range
1.3, 1.2, 0.9-1.5 1.2, 0.9, 0.9-1.4
Posterior septum wall thickness, cm
Mean, median, range
1.3, 1.1, 0.9-1.5 1.2, 0.7, 0.9-1.5
Left Ventricular features Assessment End-systolic diameter, cm
Mean, median, range
3.8, 3.6, 2.8-4.6 3.4, 3.4, 2.7-5.9
End-diastolic diameter, cm
Mean, median, range
5.4, 5.2, 4.3-6.4 4.8, 4.9, 3.9-5.9  
End-systolic volume, mL
Mean, median, range
52, 53, 29-96 42, 41, 22-66  
End- diastolic volume, mL
Mean, median, range
145, 146, 95-190 127, 127, 85-170  
Relative wall thickness, cm
Mean, median, range
0.7, 0.7, 0.4-0.9 0.6, 0.6, 0.4-1.7  
*Geometry, n=   p-value  
Normal geometry 2 (3%) 10 (14%)   0.030  
Concentric hypertrophy 54 (74%) 28 (38%) <0.001  
Eccentric hypertrophy
Concentric remodeling
4 (5%)
16 (22%)
12 (16%)   0.111
25 (34%)   0.201
Ejection fraction,%
Mean, median, range
65, 65, 47-80 68, 67, 58-84  

Table 2: Cardiovascular parameters assessments before and after the antithyroid therapy (AtT) in the patients with toxic diffuse goiter.

Statistical analysis

For univariate statistical analysis purpose, the Statistica software system (version 12.0, StatSoft Scandinavia AB, Sweden) was used. In order to evaluate the studied parameters’ differences two-tailed Fisher’s exact test and Wilcoxon signedrank test were applied and the statistical significance was set to p<0.01. The STATA/SE software system (version 13.0, StataCorp, TX, USA) was used to perform the regression analysis. The correlation of various factors such as age, systolic BP, TSH, BMI, free T3, TPOAb, free T4, TRAb, with respect to variations in left ventricular geometry in both analyses was tested in the linear regression. The p-value<0.05 was taken as statistically significant criterion for the results.


Clinical assessments outcomes with respect to

Physical features: The detailed outcomes of clinical assessment of patients before (means at baseline) and after (means after follow up) anti-thyroid therapy (AtT) are shown in Table 3. Total 70% (51) women and 30% (22) men of 50 years old (mean age with range 32-66) were present among 73 patients. They were followed up for 6 months after the diagnosis (range 4-12). The respective values of BMI, BSA and mean body weight were 72 kg, 24.8 kg/m2 and 1.78 m2 at the time of diagnosis and after the AtT they changed to 74 kg, 26.1 kg/m2 and 1.84 m2, respectively.

  Features Patients (n=73)
Before AtT After AtT
Physical features Assessment Weight, kg    
Mean, median, range 72, 70, 48-112 74, 71, 53-116
BMI, kg/m2    
Mean, median, range 24.8, 23.9, 15.6-36.5 26.1, 25.2, 15.6-40.6
BSA, m2    
Mean, median, range 1.78, 1.75, 1.5-2.2 1.84, 1.82, 1.6-2.3
Hyperthyroidism features Assessment Size of thyroid, cm3    
Left lobe (Mean, median, range) 44, 30, 10-180 60, 43, 11-210
Right lobe (Mean, median, range) 48, 30, 14-210 65, 54, 14-225
Thyroid eye disease    
Yes/No 52 (71%) /21 (29%) 14 (19%) /59 (81%)
TSH, mIU/L    
Mean, median, range 0.025, 0.006, 0.003-0.07 3.1, 2.7, 0.006-54.7
Free T3, pmol/L    
Mean, median, range 28.6, 26.2, 4.8-56 6.1, 5.8, 3.2-9.6
Free T4, pmol/L    
Mean, median, range 82.9, 80, 26.6-330 16.4, 15.8, 1.4-34
TRAb, IU/L    
Mean, median, range 108, 35, 0.9-3581 29, 14, 0.9-312
TPOAb, kIU/L    
Mean, median, range 291, 147, 5.9-6022 120, 64, 5.2-1145

Table 3: Clinical assessments of the patients before and after the antithyroid therapy (AtT).

Hyperthyroidism features: Assistance of ultrasonography was taken and detected that around 93% (68) patients had enlarged thyroid, at baseline. Size of thyroid of left lobe and right lobe were 44 cm3 and 48 cm3, respectively. After AtT, significant increase in their respective volumes (60 cm3 and 65 cm3) was observed. Thyroid eye disease was shown in 52 (71%) patients at baseline and in 14 (19%) patients after AtT. Low concentrations of TSH (0.025 mIU/L, mean) confirmed the presence of hyperthyroidism but a significant increase in it (up to 3.1 mIU/mL) after AtT was seen. The values of thyroid hormones concentrations before and after AtT of free T3 (28.6 vs. 6.1 pmol/L), free T4 (82.9 vs. 16.4 pmol/L) suggested that all the patients exhibited overt hyperthyroidism and then restored to euthyroid state. Besides, increase in TSH concentrations (more than 0.1 mIU/L) in 59 (81%) patients after AtT was also observed and thus supported the decrease in free T3 and T4 concentrations. Thus it can also be said that 14 (19%) patients were diagnosed with a subclinical hyperthyroidism without clinical manifestations. On the other hand, thyroid autoantibodies: TRAb (108 vs. 29 IU/L), TPOAb (291 vs. 120 kIU/L), showed similar trend of decrease in their concentrations after AtT.

Cardiovascular parameters assessments outcomes

Physiology, heart sizes and left ventricular features: Table 2 shows noteworthy gains in cardiovascular physiology, heart sizes and left ventricular parameters after AtT. Physiological analyses showed decrease in heart rate (from 124 to 76 bpm), systolic bp (from 158 to 126 mm Hg) and diastolic bp (from 85 to 68 mm Hg) after AtT. Similarly, heart sizes showed significant decrease in terms of mass (from 230 to 195 g) and mass index (from 131 to 108 g/m2) of left ventricular, dimension of left atrium (from 4.1 to 3.8 cm) and septum wall thickness of interventricular and posterior (from 1.3 to 1.2 cm) after AtT. Besides, most left ventricular parameters also showed decrease in diameters and volumes in both the endsystolic (from 3.8 to 3.4 cm; from 52 to 42 mL, respectively) and in end-diastolic (from 5.4 to 4.8 cm; from 145 to 127 mL, respectively) features after AtT while rest left ventricular parameters showed increase in terms of geometry and ejection fraction after AtT (Table 2).

Rhythmic disorders: A decrease in cardiac rhythm disorders (Table 4) in euthyroid patients (i.e. after AtT) was observed when the cardiovascular parameters in terms of pulmonary high bp (from 16 (22%) to 4 (6%)), arterial high bp (from 69 (95%) to 2 (2%)), thyrotoxic cardiomyopathy (from 57 (78%) to 18 (24%)), atrial fibrillation (from 52 (71%) to 14 (19%)), congestive cardiac failure (from 50 (68%) to 13 (18%)) and ventricular extrasystole (from 53 (72%) to 5 (7%)) were further analyzed.

Features Patients (n=73)
Before AtT After AtT
Pulmonary high bp    
Yes/No 16 (22%) /57 (78%) 4 (6%) /69 (94%)
Arterial high bp    
Yes/No 69 (95%) /4 (5%) 2 (2%) /71 (82%)
Thyrotoxic cardiomyopathy    
Yes/No 57 (78%) /16 (22%) 18 (24%) /55 (76%)
Atrial fibrillation    
Yes/No 52 (71%) /21 (29%) 14 (19%) /59 (81%)
Congestive cardiac failure    
Yes/No 50 (68%) /23 (32%) 13 (18%) /60 (82%)
Ventricular extrasystole    
Yes/No 53 (72%) /20 (28%) 5 (7%) /68 (93%)

Table 4: Assessments of cardiac rhythm disorders secondary to toxic diffuse goiter before and after the antithyroid therapy (AtT).

Left ventricular geometry outcomes

Table 2 showed the detection of all types of left ventricular geometry in our study cohort. A normal left ventricular geometry was diagnosed in 2 (3%) patients at baseline, while it was changed to 10 (14%) patients after AtT (p=0.030). But a significant reversal was observed in the case of concentric hypertrophy (from 54 (74%) to 28 (38%); p-value<0.001) thus the normalization of left ventricular mass was observed. Only TRAb could predict the changes in left ventricular geometry features during univariate analysis b-coefficient=0.028 (95% CI 0.00-0.07). Similar type of noteworthy association between TRAb and changes in left ventricular geometry features was also observed in multivariate analysis. Other factors had no noteworthy association in both the analysis (data not shown).

Effect of AtT on QLrH

Noteworthy gains of QLrH were observed in all the six dimensions as shown in Table 5 and Figure 1. Our analysis showed that after AtT the problems related to anxiety (34 (97%) vs 22 (63%)) and depression (33 (95%) vs. 23 (65%)) eliminated in around 30% patients (p<0.005). Similar pattern was shown by analyses of problems related to pain (34 (97%) vs. 22 (63%)) and discomfort (33 (95%) vs. 23 (65%)) after AtT. However, after the treatment, 8 (23%) and 14 (40%) patients reported elimination of problems related to self-care and mobility dimensions, respectively, which is respectively thrice and twice less frequent as compared to 23 (65%) and 30 (85%) cases before AtT.


Figure 1: Representative diagram of the questionnaire answered by patients with respect to six dimensions as anxiety, depression, pain, mobility, discomfort and self-care in five levels from 1 to 5 for no problem, slight problem, moderate problem, severe problem and extreme problem, respectively, for the assessment of QLrH.

Features Patients (n=35)
Before AtT After AtT
Anxiety problems*    
Yes/No 34 (97%) /1 (3%) 22 (63%) /13 (37%)
Depression problems*    
Yes/No 33 (95%) /2 (5%) 23 (65%) /12 (35%)
Pain problems    
Yes/No 34 (97%) /1 (3%) 22 (63%) /13 (37%)
Mobility problems    
Yes/No 30 (85%)/ 5 (15%) 14 (40%)/ 21 (60%)
Discomfort problems    
Yes/No 33 (95%) /2 (5%) 23 (65%) /12 (35%)
Self-care problems    
Yes/No           23 (65%) /12 (35%) 8 (23%) /27 (77%)

Table 5: Assessments of quality of life related to health (QLrH) using our questionnaire before and after the antithyroid therapy (AtT).


Thyrotoxic heart disease associated cardiovascular complexities and QLrH through hyperthyroidism in Chinese patients diagnosed with TDG were investigated. A strong association between the omission of cardiovascular disorders and gains in QLrH and the restoration of the euthyroid state was found. Broadly speaking, thyrotoxic heart disease secondary to toxic diffuse goiter was analyzed in order to set up relationship between cardiovascular symptoms and QLrH. It was established that TDG has significant impact on development related to cardiovascular complexities and also on the normalization of cardiac functions at the euthyroid state and this result is quite consistent to the previous works [3,7,8,30]. Since thyroid hormones directly affect the sinoatrial node [38], it might be the reason for our finding that the resting heart rate in all patients was elevated before AtT and it is commonly reported as rhythmic disorders in patients of TDG. In the line with other reports [39,40], a reversal of ventricular extrasystole and atrial fibrillation to normal rhythm of the heart after the restoration of euthyroidism was also found.

It was diagnosed that more than half of the patients with damaged QLrH and hyperthyroidism had congestive cardiac failure and atrial fibrillation and thus these disorders had no negative impact on QL. The diagnosis results of remodeling of left ventricular geometry and thyrotoxic cardiomyopathy secondary to TDG before AtT is in agreement with a previous report [7]. Our findings suggest that the anti-thyroid drugs play an essential role in early detection and treatment of hyperthyroidism which leads to prevention and reversibility of thyrotoxic cardiomyopathy, as reported elsewhere [7]. Reversal of concentric hypertrophy to left ventricular geometry of various types as well as noteworthy gains of other left ventricular parameters was also observed. Arterial high bp was diagnosed in 95% of patients and which lead to high systolic bp because excess of thyroid hormones is responsible for elevation in the resting rate of heart and volume of blood [38]. The association between diminished QLrH and arterial high bp secondary to TDG was also shown. Earlier reports [7,38,39] showed major impact of the excess of thyroid hormones on the cardiomyocytes and thus the favorable effect of β-adrenergic receptor antagonists’ and ACE inhibitors’ gain of left ventricular remodeling [41,42] have supported our work of restoration of euthyroid state. Thus it could be hypothesized that even in relatively short follow up time cardiovascular parameters might show improvement when euthyroidism was restored using β-adrenergic receptor antagonists and ACE inhibitors based AtT. In majority of patients, the thyroid autoantibodies TRAb and TPOAb were found. It was also determined that TRAb was an independent predictor of changes in left ventricular geometry but its impact on left ventricular geometry was specifically indirected by stimulating the synthesis of thyroid hormones and thus subsequently affected the cardiomyocytes [3].

Assessment of QLrH with our questionnaire showed decreasing of physical activity dimensions (i.e. mobility and self-care problems) followed by their noteworthy gains after AtT. These problems happened in hyperthyroid patients due to dramatic increase in cardiac work which in turn leads to low ability for adequate response to exercises and myocardial hypertrophy. High frequency of problems related to anxiety, depression, pain and discomfort dimensions which is previously reported in patients of hyperthyroidism, subclinical hyperthyroidism and TDG [9,29] was also found. In the line of previous reports [9,29,38] association of stabilization of hemodynamic parameters, elimination of thyrotoxic heart disease in around 30% of patients and reduction in the problems in majority of patients was achieved even when the volume of goiter was increased after AtT. Besides, an association between significant reduction of anxiety and depression dimensions and elimination of hyperthyroidism was also found as reported elsewhere [27-29]. These two dimensions had negative impact on QLrH in patients with thyrotoxic heart disease but these disorders were diminished after euthyroidism restoration. In order to existence of pathophysiological relation between neurotransmitter based mental health and the excess of thyroid based hormones, the scientific community found the presence of these two mood disorders in hyperthyroid patients as a common report [8,9]. The only limitation to our study is that relatively less numbers of participants were used even then our results lie in the line of those studies which used larger numbers of participants [7,30,39].

In conclusion, it can be said that it is the first ever report of evaluation of QLrH in Chinese patients with thyrotoxic heart disease secondary to TDG. Our analyses have discovered the hyperthyroidism’s influence on the health of patients followed by noteworthy gain in QLrH as well as the omission of cardiovascular complexities due to thyrotoxic heart disease by subsequent normalization of thyroid hormones concentrations in greater number of patients.