Research Article - Biomedical Research (2016) Volume 27, Issue 4
Accepted April 11, 2016
Quantitative measurement of mechanical properties of cervix is an effective tool to diagnose cervical insufficiency, specifically in the last trimester of pregnancy when preterm birth is mostly probable to occur. The objective of this study was to characterize the viscoelastic behavior of rat cervix at different displacement levels and rates early in the last trimester of pregnancy. Distinct displacement levels and rates were employed to measure the tensile and load-relaxation properties of cervices from 16 days postconception pregnant rats. After preconditioning, 2 millimeters uniaxial displacement was applied to the distal halves of five rat’s cervices circumferentially at displacement rates of 0.01, 0.1 and 1 mm/sec. This displacement was held for 10 minutes while the tissues were mostly relaxed. The same procedure was repeated for the displacement levels of 1, 1.5 and 2 millimeters at the rate of 1 mm/sec. Tensile and loadrelaxation curves were well described by a quasi-linear viscoelastic model. Statistical analysis revealed significant correlation between the change in displacement levels and rates, and the elastic response of the tissues. The viscous response, though, did not show strong dependency on displacement levels as well as displacement rates. Cervix becomes considerably stiffer and exhibits less viscous effects in increasing rates. However, higher displacement levels result in lower strength of the tissue. These results show the viscoelastic behavior of cervix in the last trimester of pregnancy. These mechanical characterizations may be useful for prediction of cervical insufficiency and preterm birth
Cervical insufficiency, Preterm birth, Viscoelastic behavior, Displacement levels and rates.
Characterization of viscoelastic behavior of cervix will provide insight to the changes of elastic and viscous responses of the tissue during pregnancy. This detailed knowledge will help us understand the effect of clinical and physiological variables on the normal functional behavior of the pregnant tissue. The cervix is a mechanical barrier that holds the growing fetus inside and stays firm until the fetus is mature. At the time of delivery, the cervical tissue softens and ripens to allow the baby to pass . Cervical Insufficiency refers to a condition in which cervix dilates asymptomatically in the absence of contractions from the uterine smooth muscles and results in a spontaneous pregnancy loss between the second and third trimester of pregnancy. Cervical Insufficiency accounts for a significant percentage of extremely premature deliveries with high incidence of infant mortality .
Changes in mechanical properties of cervix during pregnancy, is a result of microstructural and compositional changes happen as gestational age increases. These changes include increase in the tissue hydration, collagen extractability and sulfated glycosaminoglycan content but the amount of collagen content remains the same [3,4]. These changes may cause the tissue to lose its mechanical properties, especially in the last trimester of pregnancy, and becomes insufficient to retain the fetus until term. In this case preterm birth is most likely to happen . Characterizing the material behavior of human cervical tissue using either in vivo or ex vivo methodologies remains a challenge. Each methodology has advantages and drawbacks in terms of its ability to capture tissue remodeling characteristics of pregnant tissue or to obtain enough data to derive fully predictive 3D constitutive material equations. Animal models of pregnancy offer opportunities to test gestation timed, genetically-altered, or chemically-treated samples. However, it is unclear whether the factors driving tissue remodeling in these animal models are similar enough to humans .
Ex vivo mechanical tests allow for control over definitions of boundary and loading conditions such that careful analysis of the tissue’s stress response to various loading scenarios can be assessed. A large range of variation reported for human cervical tissue tangent moduli which are due to the variation in testing protocols, tissue age and parity between the studies [7,8]. In vivo interrogation of the cervix during pregnancy allows characterization of longitudinal changes over the course of the gestation. The driving motivation for the development of the in vivo tools is both investigational and diagnostic in nature, where the ultimate clinical goal is to uncover cervical biomarkers that are predictive of preterm birth .
Bishop score is a primary method used via a digital examination of the cervix, which measures both structural and material parameters such as effacement, dilation and softness . These measurements can be highly variable due to the subjective nature of each component and lack of precision. Transvaginal ultrasound techniques have been popularly used recently to measure anatomical parameters of cervix, such as changes in the length of the tissue during pregnancy [10,11]. Although anatomical parameters are useful indicators of preterm birth, but these measurements alone have low predictive value and in many cases did not outperform the bishop score in predicting preterm birth [12,13]. Ultrasound elastography is a method recently used in the field of gynecology. Semi-quantitative elastography can be employed to evaluate changes in cervical stiffness during pregnancy. This method estimates the average tissue displacement (strain) within a defined region of interest when oscillatory compression is applied. However, this method is a good predictor of cervical function but before it can be used, the mechanical properties of tissue must be characterized .
Due to the limitations of human cervical tissue sampling, rodent models have been widely used to investigate for understanding physiological changes of the cervix during pregnancy. Despite the differences in the mechanical properties of the rat cervix to the humans, the timing and degree of change makes it as a good candidate for understanding events that precede preterm birth [15,16]. Table 1 summarizes uniaxial tests results reported in the literature for the rat cervical tissue. Each study measured the QLV model constants at defined displacement levels and rates [4,16].
|References||Specimen description||Strain rate & Strain level||Tangent modulus (MPa)||QLV model constants|
|W. Barone et al., 2010||NP, MP and PP Term, Long Evans rat cervix Rectangular specimen, Compression test||Rate: 0.167 mm/s Level: 0.2||Not given||B ex. os NP:38.8|
|B ex. os MP:53.4|
|B ex. os PP:39.9|
|D ex. os NP:0.124|
|D ex. os MP:0.143|
|D ex. os PP:0.148|
|MJ. Poellmann et al., 2012||PG Term (15-21 days pregnancy), Sprague-Dawley rat cervix, Tensile test||Rate: 0.02 mm/s Level: 0.25||K Day 15: 66.21 g/mm||B ex. os Day 15: 2.3|
|K Day 21:7.34 g/mm||B ex. os Day 21: 1.6|
Table 1. Rat cervical tissue tangent moduli and QLV model constants from uniaxial ex vivo mechanical tests. The strain level reported is location of the tangent modulus. PG: Pregnant, NP: Non-Pregnant, MP: Mid-Pregnant, PP: Post-Partum, ex: External.
Accurate diagnostic criteria and treatment guidelines for prediction of preterm birth in case of cervical insufficiency are not established and remains a clinical and research challenge. Quantitative mechanical diagnostic techniques have been gaining in popularity in diagnosis of cervical insufficiency . Therefore the objective of this study was to characterize the viscoelastic response of rat cervix at different displacement levels and rates in the last trimester of pregnancy. These characterizations may enhance the development of medical devices which measure the viscoelastic response of human cervix to defined applied variables for diagnosis of the abnormal behavior of tissues.
All procedures were approved by the institutional animal care and use committee at the University of Tehran. The samples were obtained from the Animal Lab of the Veterinary Surgery Department of the University of Tehran. Twenty Virgin Wistar rats with the same characteristics (age, weight) were kept in five different boxes and were mated by male ones at a definite time. After a night males removed and five rats were found to be pregnant. After euthanasia with carbon dioxide, cervices were harvested from 16 days post-conception pregnant rats early in the last trimester of pregnancy (full term ̴ 22 days). The cervix was excised from the uterus at the transition zone. Then each cervix was cut in half perpendicular to the cervical canal, as illustrated in Figure 1a. Cervical mucus was not removed prior to testing to prevent damage resulting from its removal. The distal halves were kept in normal saline and taken immediately to the laboratory for mechanical testing to avoid tissue damage or change of in-vivo mechanical properties. The proximal portion has been shown to have higher smooth muscle and less collagen content compared to the distal portion . Table 2 presents the information on collected specimens.
Figure 1A. Illustration of the rat cervix. Cervix was excised from the uterus at the transition zone. Then each cervix was cut in half perpendicular to the cervical canal. The distal halves were kept in normal saline and taken immediately to the laboratory for mechanical testing. The rat cervix has two canals one leading to each uterine horn. For mechanical testing, stainless steel rods were threaded through each canal.
|No.||Width (mm)||Length (mm)||Thickness (mm)|
Table 2. Sample information (Cervices samples from Wistar rats of age 7 months with 250 ± 10 grams weight)
The length, width and thickness of the each half were measured using digital calipers with an accuracy of ± 0.01. A pair of steel rods each 1 mm diameter, were threaded through the cervical canals. The rods were placed into a custom-made fixture, as shown in Figure 1b. Once the cervix was placed in the fixture, the distance between the rods was measured to ensure that the dimensions were not changed by the calipers due to deformation. All tensile tests were performed by a uniaxial test device, designed and fabricated to measure mechanical properties of soft biological tissues . The testing device is equipped with a 10-N load cell with an accuracy of ± 0.5 %.
Displacement controlled tensile loadings were implemented to the samples circumferentially in medial-lateral direction. In order to obtain a repeatable mechanical behavior, tissues were preconditioned. For this purpose, samples underwent 10 cycles of loading-unloading at low displacement levels at the rate of 1 mm/sec to coincide stress-strain curves. After preconditioning, the displacement of 2 millimeters was applied to the samples circumferentially. The displacement rates of 0.01, 0.1 and 1 mm/sec were employed to carry out the tension tests at the ramp section. They defined as low rate, mid-rate and high rate, respectively. Furthermore, Samples were stretched to the displacement levels of 1, 1.5 and 2 millimeters at the rate of 1 mm/sec to investigate the effect of displacement levels on the viscoelastic response of the tissue. A recovery period of 5 minutes was considered between tests. To study the relaxation behavior of tissues, the displacement was held for 10 minutes while the tissues were mostly relaxed, as illustrated in Figure 1c. Samples were sprayed with saline solution to prevent drying of the tissue during the experiments. Force, displacement and time were collected at 30 Hz.
Stress and strain were calculated using the force and displacement measured in the tests as functions of time. Curve fitting tool in Matlab was used to fit best quasi-linear viscoelastic (QLV) models to the stress-strain and stress-time curves using least square method. To analyze material properties of cervix, stress was calculated by normalizing load by the cross-sectional area and strain was defined as tissue displacement divided by initial internal width. A rectangular geometry was assumed for all samples .
Elastic modulus (E) was defined as the slope of the linear region of stress-strain curves at the end of each ramp and defined in MPa . The tensile and load-relaxation data were fit to a quasi-linear viscoelastic (QLV) model . The quasilinear viscoelastic (QLV) model parameters were extracted to compare the viscoelastic properties of samples at different displacement levels and rates. A coefficient of determination R2>0.9 was considered for the acceptance of the best model fitted.
The instantaneous elastic response of the tissues was described by the QLV model as a function of strain (Equation 1):
Where parameter B indicates the rate of change in the slope of the stress-strain curves. The relaxation behavior of tissues was well described by a four-parameter function which closely fit the stress of the hold section as a function of time (Equation 2):
Where parameters D and F indicate the slope of the short term and long term relaxation of the stress-time curves.
Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS statistics 18 software. One way ANOVA was used to study the significance of the independent variables namely, displacement levels and rates, on measured viscoelastic properties of the samples. A Pvalue of less than 0.05 was considered as significant statistical difference. This limit can be extended due to the diversity of the viscoelastic response of the tissue. Furthermore, a Duncan post-hoc test was carried out to classify the results at different displacement levels and rates. The estimated QLV parameters were represented graphically with box plots.
The uniaxial tension tests performed on 5 samples from cervices of 16 days post-conception pregnant rats. Each sample was tested at three different displacement levels and rates. Results revealed that the elastic modulus slightly increased at high rate compared to low rate and mid-rate, as illustrated in Figure 2a (p=0.215). The difference between the elastic modulus was found significant particularly at high rate and low rate (p=0.024). Though, the elastic modulus did not change considerably in increasing displacement levels, as shown in Figure 2b (p=0.744).
Parameter B, which is the rate of change in the slope of the elastic response and governs the nonlinearity of the stressstrain curve, was found to increase significantly as rate increased, as illustrated in Figure 2c (p=0.000). A Duncan post-hoc test showed that the mean B values of tissues at low rate and mid-rate were in the same subset while it increased considerably at high rate. In addition, Parameter B showed considerable dependency on displacement levels and decreased significantly in increasing levels (p = 0.029). A Duncan posthoc test showed that the mean B values of tissues at displacement levels of 1.5 and 2 millimeters were in the same subset while it was considerably higher at the level of 1 millimeter (Figure 2d).
The uniaxial tension test was held at the defined displacement level for 10 minutes while the tissues were mostly relaxed. Parameter D, which represents the initial slope of the relaxation curve, slightly increased at higher displacement rates, as illustrated in Figure 3a (p=0.219). It was found that D value differs considerably at high rate and low rate (p=0.07). In addition, no significant difference was seen for parameter D in increasing displacement levels, as shown in Figure 3b (p=0.421).
For parameter F, which represents the late slope of the relaxation curve, no difference was detected as displacement rate increased, as illustrated in Figure 3c (p = 0.58). Furthermore, higher displacement levels did not result in change of parameter F, as shown in Figure 3d (p=0.99).
Quantification of viscoelastic properties of rat cervix in the last trimester of pregnancy has been done in previous studies [4,16]. Nevertheless, this was the first work to study the effect of different displacement levels and rates on viscoelastic properties of rat cervix in late stage of pregnancy. Additionally, unlike some previous studies based on structural properties of the tissue, the intrinsic material properties of cervix were estimated which are independent of the sample geometry and size. The results of our study strongly proved that the pregnant tissue is rate dependent and its viscoelastic properties change at different displacement levels and rates.
The critical parameters estimated by tensile and load-relaxation curves utilizing QLV theory were the rate of change in the slope of the elastic response B, and the initial and late slope of the relaxation curve, D and F. The elastic modulus and parameter B, associated with the elastic response of cervix, increased as displacement rate increased. Though, the parameter B significantly decreased in increasing displacement levels. These changes show that by increasing the displacement rate tissue becomes stiffer and its nonlinearity increases as well, while tissue’s softening behavior occurs in increasing displacement levels. It was found that increasing the displacement rates result in increase of the initial slope of the relaxation curves. The late slope of the relaxation curves did not change in increasing displacement levels and rates. As Equation 3 defines, the time constant of the relaxation curve (τ) is equal to the viscous parameter (η) divided by the elastic modulus (E) of the tissue. What can be found is that by increasing the displacement rate, pregnant tissues relax faster and the time at which relaxation terminates reduces which is due to less viscous parameter affecting.
The increased strength of cervix at higher displacement rates is desirable, specifically in the beginning of the last trimester of pregnancy when preterm birth is mostly probable to occur in case of cervical insufficiency. The softening behavior of the pregnant tissue at higher levels of displacement reduces its resistance to abrupt loads early in the last trimester of pregnancy. This strength reduction can be a major cause of spontaneous preterm birth while higher physiological strains are inserted to the cervix. Additionally, less viscous effect enables the tissue to recover faster to its steady state. This fast recovery allows for loads to be dissipated more quickly. These changes may enhance the ability of the cervix to maintain load bearing capacity and efficient absorption of the loads. These changes are related to the altered matrix organization and porosity of the pregnant tissue reported by others [3,21].
Consequently, increase of tissue’s strength in increasing displacement rates and its decrease in increasing displacement levels is probable for the pregnant cervix. Furthermore, decrease of the viscous effects in increasing displacement rates enhances the dissipation ability and load absorption of the tissue. These changes in mechanical properties may provide criteria for the normal viscoelastic behavior of the pregnant cervix. Tissues not responding to the applied variables with such a trend are known as abnormal and predicted to have the potential of cervical insufficiency early in the last trimester of pregnancy. This hypothesis must be further studied clinically on human cases to be widely approved.
There are some limitations of this study to be considered for the future works. Despite cervical insufficiency and preterm birth occurs early in the last trimester of pregnancy, more time points are needed to measure the viscoelastic properties of cervix at distinct displacement levels and rates. The second limitation is that mechanical testing is limited to static loading, so the static viscoelastic properties were obtained. Dynamic mechanical analysis is essential to know the dependency of the complex viscoelastic properties of cervix to the desired variables. Assuming rectangular geometry for the tissue was used for the simplicity to estimate material properties of the samples. This assumption may affect the mechanical test results estimated.
The goal of this work was to characterize the viscoelastic behavior of rat cervix at different displacement levels and rates early in the last trimester of pregnancy. The tensile and loadrelaxation parameters change as displacement levels and rates increase. Cervix becomes considerably stiffer and exhibits less viscous effects in increasing rates. However, higher displacement levels result in lower strength of the tissue. These results show the viscoelastic behavior of cervix in the last trimester of pregnancy. These mechanical characterizations may be useful for prediction of cervical insufficiency and preterm birth.
All applicable international, national and institutional guidelines for the care and use of animals were followed.